Saturday 6 September 2003

Italy 31 Georgia 22

Italy made hard work of a tough Georgia side when the two countries met at the Stadio Comunale Censin Bosia in the Italian town of Asti in a pre-World Cup Test, with the Azzurri taking the spoils by a 31-22 margin only.

The sides were tied 13-13 at the break, and the Lelos of Georgia even had to battle on without their full numbers, after fullback Bessik Khamashuridze and lock Zurab Mtchedlishvili were both sin-binned -- Khamashuridze then being red-carded later in the match.

Italian props Leandro Castrogiovanni and Andrea Lo Cicero scored first-half tries to add to a Ramiro Pez penalty, while Lelos wing Makho Urjukashvili scored their only try of the game on the half hour mark.

The second half saw Italy score tries through their two most-capped players of all time, captain Alessandro Troncon and back rower Carlo Checchinato.

Georgia, meanwhile, had the boot of fly-half Pavle Jimsheladze to thank for the majority of their points with a string of penalties and a conversion for their try, while centre Makho Urjukashvili dropped a goal during the physical encounter.

Italy:  1 Leandro Castrogiovanni, 2 Fabio Ongaro, 3 Andrea Lo Cicero, 4 Marco Bortolami, 5 Santiago Dellape, 6 Andrea De Rossi, 7 Aaron Persico, 8 Sergio Parisse, 9 Alessandro Troncon (c), 10 Ramiro Pez, 11 Mirco Bergamasco, 12 Giovanni Raineri, 13 Cristian Stoica, 14 Nicola Mazzucato, 15 Gonzalo Canale
Reserves:  Carlo Festuccia, Gert Peens, Mauro Bergamasco, Carlo Checchinato, Salvatore Perugini, Juan Manuel Queirolo
Unused:  Vincenzo Zullo

Georgia:  1 Avtandil Kopaliani, 2 Akvsenti Guiorgadze, 3 Aleko Margvelashvili, 4 Victor Didebulidze, 5 Zurab Mtchedlishvili, 6 George Chkhaidze, 7 Gregoire Yachvili, 8 Ilia Zedguinidze (c), 9 Irakli Abusseridze, 10 Paliko Jimsheladze, 11 Makho Urjukashvili, 12 Irakli Guiorgadze, 13 Tedo Zibzibadze, 14 Irakli Machkhaneli, 15 Bessik Khamashuridze
Reserves:  David Dadunashvili, Vano Nadiradze, Gocha Khonelidze, David Kiknadze, Goderdzi Shvelidze, Guia Labadze, Irakli Modebadze

Attendance:  6000
Referee:  Ramage i.

Points Scorers:

Italy
Tries:  Troncon A. 1, Lo Cicero A. 1, Castrogiovanni M.L. 1, Checchinato C. 1
Conv:  Pez R. 1
Pen K.:  Pez R. 3

Georgia
Tries:  Urjukashvili M. 1
Conv:  Jimsheladze P. 1
Pen K.:  Jimsheladze P. 4
Drop G.:  Urjukashvili M. 1

Ireland 29 Scotland 10

Ireland's last visit to Murrayfield ended in a record Six Nations win over their hosts seven months ago, but for Eddie O'Sullivan's charges the only thing broken at the Edinburgh venue was Geordan Murphy's left leg, as his side won 29-10.

Tries from wings Denis Hickie and Anthony Horgan and bustling centre Kevin Maggs cemented the Irish win, on a frustrating final afternoon at the home of Scottish rugby for coaching tandem Ian McGeechan and Jim Telfer -- but the game was ultimately overshadowed by Murphy's 19th-minute injury.

Shifting his weight under a heavy double tackle from Andy Craig and lock Nathan Hines, the Leicester Tiger fell awkwardly to the ground near the Scottish 10-metre line.

In the ensuing minutes, with the Irish medical team ensconced on the halfway line, and a stretcher being readied, you could forgive many of the Irish players for retreating to inside their 22, evidently distancing themselves from the scene of one of their most pivotal players, with hands on head and his World Cup dreams in tatters.

While Murphy was taken to hospital with a suspected broken left leg, Scotland created and penetrated opportunities, but failed to convert their first-half chances.  Wing Chris Paterson, entrusted with the kicking duties, left Victor Costello unpunished, following a left-sided penalty in the second minute.

Ronan O'Gara, returning to first team duty for the first time since the June trip to Samoa, also missed his first kick at the posts as the game took the shape of a rust-laden pre-season friendly.

It took 22 minutes for the first score of the game to be landed from the boot of Paterson, his first success at the third attempt, following Murphy's fall and subsequent sidelining.

Prop Reggie Corrigan and mercurial centre Brian O'Driscoll also hit the deck with injury in the first half, neither looking too serious, as the strain was beginning to show on Irish coaching staff in the West stand.

Strong defence from Paul O'Connell and prop Marcus Horan kept a five-phase home side out near the Irish line, nearing the half-hour, before a turnover by substitute Girvan Dempsey on Paterson, resulting in Horan stretching just two metres short of the Scottish tryline.

Ireland had their first points on the board with a 32nd minute O'Gara penalty, and four minutes later they took the lead with Kevin Maggs muscling over from close range.

A Keith Wood line-out was gobbled up by O'Connell, and from the second pick and drive Peter Stringer released the line for Maggs to squeeze through the 10-12 gap and edge over, under the tackles of Gordon Ross and Andrew Mower.  O'Gara converted to send his side in at the interval, with a 10-point lead.

Scotland almost notched a try through Allan Jacobsen and Simon Taylor in first-half injury-time, but it was the visitors who took on the initiative after 12 minutes of the second period.

Skipper Wood took an inside pass from O'Gara, and the former Harlequins hooker released try-happy Denis Hickie to sprint past substitute Simon Webster on the outside, and ground the ball before hitting the corner-flag.

That score, brilliantly converted by O'Gara, effectively sealed an Irish win and Munster wing Anthony Horgan, in his third international, scored his first try just on the hour mark.

A midfield break from Brian O'Driscoll paved the way for Horgan to steam over on the right-wing, following a massive punt forward from the influential O'Gara.

As both sets of players visibly tired from a game of running patterns, a Hickie cutback saw O'Driscoll grounded, but the Leinster centre still had the will and vision to pop a pass into the welcoming arms of back row David Wallace, sin-binned at the end of the first half, to glide over for a welcome fourth score in the 70th minute and confirmation of his return to form.

Shaven-headed Simon Webster, unfortunate to concede two tries as last man to Hickie and Horgan on his debut, crossed for a 79th minute consolation, to send Scotland down under on the back of a sole try in the past fortnight, against the Murphy-less Irish, with 17.

For Eddie O'Sullivan, his second victory at Murrayfield was unfortunately a long-faced let-down, rather than a warm-up for the pending festivities in Australia.

Man of the match:  Ireland fly-half Ronan O'Gara controlled matters in the second half tactically, and barked the back line into shape following a slow start.  Ireland, as a whole, came into their own in the second period, with Keith Wood prominent in the loose, following the loss of two of his line-outs in the first forty minutes.

Moment of the match:  Nothing could match the sight of Geordan Murphy's ankle snapping short of the Scottish 10-metre line after barely 20 minutes at Murrayfield.  Grown men winced in full view of television replays, as many questioned the validity of playing a hard-edged, full-blown Test match five weeks before the biggest rugby event in sporting history gets under way.

Villain of the match:  Unintentionally Nathan Hines' 6ft plus frame has robbed Ireland the rugby world of the running delights and World Cup potential of Geordan Murphy.  The "Tigerish" fullback looked far from "Wizard of Oz" material with a paperweight left ankle in view.  Scottish lock Hines was eventually sin-binned after half-an-hour for persistent ruck infringing.

The Teams:

Ireland:  1 Reggie Corrigan, 2 Keith Wood (c), 3 Marcus Horan, 4 Malcolm O'Kelly, 5 Paul O'Connell, 6 Eric Miller, 7 David Wallace, 8 Victor Costello, 9 Peter Stringer, 10 Ronan O'Gara, 11 Denis Hickie, 12 Brian O'Driscoll, 13 Kevin Maggs, 14 Anthony Horgan, 15 Geordan Murphy
Reserves:  Shane Byrne, Kieron Dawson, Girvan Dempsey, Simon Easterby, Guy Easterby, David Humphreys, Simon Best

Scotland:  1 Allan Jacobsen, 2 Gordon Bulloch (c), 3 Gordon McIlwham, 4 Nathan Hines, 5 Stuart Grimes, 6 Andrew Mower, 7 Ross Beattie, 8 Simon Taylor, 9 Michael Blair, 10 Gordon Ross, 11 Kenny Logan, 12 Andrew Craig, 13 Andrew Henderson, 14 Chris Paterson, 15 Glenn Metcalfe
Reserves:  Iain Fullarton, Jon Petrie, Simon Webster, James McLaren, Matthew Proudfoot, Robbie Russell
Unused:  Graeme Beveridge

Attendance:  35264
Referee:  Whitehouse n.

Points Scorers

Ireland
Tries:  Horgan A. 1, Maggs K.M. 1, Hickie D.A. 1, Wallace D.P. 1
Conv:  O'Gara R.J.R. 3
Pen K.:  O'Gara R.J.R. 1

Scotland
Tries:  Webster S. 1
Conv:  Paterson C.D. 1
Pen K.:  Paterson C.D. 1

England 45 France 14

A brace of tries by Northampton Saints wing Ben Cohen was one of many highlights for England as they cruised to a comfortable 45-14 win over France as they wrapped up their Rugby World Cup preparations at Twickenham.

Two tries from wing Ben Cohen and one from fullback Jason Robinson in the seven minutes before the half-time whistle added fuel to the fire in a dominant display, while Iain Balshaw's try 10 seconds into the second half and a late Josh Lewsey effort stamped a seal of class on to an accomplished showing.

France, without many of their star names, lacked ideas, thrust and seemingly a gameplan, as their paper-thin midfield leaked tries, although a tougher second-half performance saw them at least prevent the score from reaching 50 points, with a late try from replacement wing Aurélien Rougerie being their only touchdown of the day.

On the day that Ireland's Geordan Murphy was ruled out of the World Cup after breaking a leg in a World Cup warm-up, both Clive Woodward and Bernard Laporte will no doubt breathe a sigh of relief that none of their stars have seemingly fallen victim to the most ill-timed of injuries, although England centre Stuart Abbott did have a hint of a limp as he left the field midway through the second half, while scrum-half Kyran Bracken went off after only 33 minutes.

Star turns Jonny Wilkinson and Martin Johnson both exuded leadership and ruthlessness in their only World Cup warm-up outings, although they were both taken from the field after 43 minutes to be wrapped back up in cotton-wool before the showpiece in Australia in a month's time.

England had welcomed back a whole host of their stars for the match after their second-string fell by a single point in Marseille last week, and there were stellar displays from the likes of hooker Steve Thompson and fullback Robinson, as well as two-try hero Cohen.

With coach Clive Woodward set to name his World Cup squad on Sunday, the likes of Abbott, No.8 Martin Corry and wing Balshaw were all arguably among the main candidates playing for their places.

Balshaw showed real hunger and may well have done enough, while Abbott looked assured with some silky combination play alongside Will Greenwood -- the aggressive Corry putting in some big hits, but perhaps failing to exert the same authority as a Lawrence Dallaglio on proceedings.

For the French, some shocking tackling in the three-quarters blighted their play, with Xavier Garbajosa, Clément Poitrenaud and Yannick Jauzion being the chief culprits -- accounting for at least three of the England tries with their half-hearted efforts in contact.

Fly-half Gérald Merceron looked short of ideas, and did nothing to suggest that he will trouble Frédéric Michalak's place in the side, although he did deliver the odd deft chip and admittedly had the majority of his ball on the back foot.

Scrum-half Dimitri Yachvili suffered under the pressure from the English loose forwards, while a back row of Patrick Tabacco, Christian Labit and Sébastien Chabal never imposed themselves on the game.

It took replacement wing Rougerie to spark some life into their ailing fortunes with some barnstorming runs by the big Montferrand man down the right, as well as pulling off a magnificent try-saving tackle on Balshaw, covering for yet another weak tackle attempt by his fellow three-quarters.

Despite their heavy loss, it was actually France who led early on after scoring the first points of the game through a Merceron penalty, but a subsequent perfect four from four by Wilkinson eclipsed Les Bleus' initial efforts for a 12-3 advantage on the half-hour.

Thompson did his best Jonah Lomu impression with a powering break down the left-wing, giving the lawnmower treatment to the two unfortunate defenders in his wake, although the move broke down before a try could be scored.

French flanker Tabacco found himself an early visitor to the sin bin for a late challenge -- the only player binned all match -- and once England scored their first try on 33 minutes, the French defensive dam had been busted.

Cohen opened the try account after Wilkinson grubbered ahead in the 22, a botched attempt to handle the ball from the retreating Yachvili seeing it bounce of the post, only for the grateful Cohen to dot down.

Wilkinson converted, and only three minutes later was lining his second attempt after Cohen grabbed his another try -- a Wilkinson break seeing him off-load to Greenwood before the supporting Cohen powered over courtesy of a short pop pass on the 22.

Again, Wilkinson had no problems with the extras, and with the 'Men in White' now totally dominant, fullback Robinson -- who looked dangerous all game -- decided to have a sprint for the line from 50 metres down the left-wing, some slipshod French tackling seeing the Sale Sharks flyer breeze home virtually unopposed after Poitrenaud's challenge dissolved without a fizz.

Even from the left touchline the conversion was no trouble for Wilkinson, with his side going into the interval with a massive 33-3 scoreline to their credit.

And 10 seconds into the second half they ran in their fourth try, Balshaw magnificently collecting a switched kick-off and haring past Garbajosa down the right-wing while the crowd were still getting back to their seats.

But, given the flood of scoring that had preceded it, the next 40 minutes proved barren for the English, who plugged away with solid play but could not breach the renewed French defence, which had finally found some fight after a shaky start -- buoyed by the introduction of veteran forwards Olivier Magne and Fabien Pelous from the bench.

Replacement wing Rougerie made a big impact and almost scored twice out wide on the right, only some last ditch England defence saving them, while the hosts too showed adventure, Grayson delivering a sublime pass to Balshaw down the right-wing, only to see the Bath man's chip go into touch near the corner-flag.

At 38-3 down, and with the game well beyond them, the French then took the remarkable decision to kick for goal when given a penalty near the 22, Merceron slotting it through to the deafening ring of boos from the agitated Twickenham crowd.

Having finally found some rhythm, France mounted some sound attacks, hooker Ibanez ploughing through a midfield gap on the 22 only to be stopped just short, while a solid tackle from Abbott stopped Rougerie converting a cross-field bomb into a score in the corner.

Abbott then limped off the field, but England still pressed -- Balshaw twice going close to scoring with an attack down the right and then a fumbled attempt to clutch a Grayson chip from under the crossbar.

As if Merceron's penalty attempt was not bizarre enough, centre Jauzion then took proceedings into the twilight zone with his extraordinary decision to opt for an impromptu drop-goal on the 22.  While it went through the posts, it stank of the desperation and typified the lack of ideas besetting the French at times.

With the game ambling towards its final minutes after a quiet period, a flowing break down the left-wing brought some life back to the crowd, with Cohen spinning a beautifully weighted pass to replacement lock Simon Shaw.

The recycle saw breaks from West and Greenwood, before the ball found its way to Dawson from 10 metres out -- the scrum-half drawing his man before popping a perfect pass for Lewsey to crash over the line for a try, converted by Grayson.

But that was not to be the final score of the match, as replacement wing Rougerie was rewarded for his persistence and endeavour, touching down in the right corner in the fifth minute of stoppage time after a desperate hack from Yachvili somehow found its way to Pelous, who was lingering in the backline -- Rougerie finishing off from short range after stepping inside Robinson.

Merceron missed the conversion from way out wide, leaving French coach Bernard Laporte to ponder his options going into the World Cup, after a match which confirmed that depth may well be a problem if their frontline stars go down.

For England, a perfect send-off to the World Cup, with their blistering spell before the interval taking them a plane above their opponents, although their failure to make the most of some chances elsewhere in the match may still be a nagging annoyance to the perfectionist coaches, despite the undoubted creative headway made by all and sundry in white.

Man of the match:  A tough choice given the number of accomplished displays from those in the (skintight) England shirts, with hooker Steve Thompson and fullback Jason Robinson both failing to put a foot wrong all match.  But, for his explosive impact just before the break, and some try-saving challenges, left-wing Ben Cohen gets our nod.  From the French ranks the candidates are few and far between after a dismal early performance, although replacement wing Aurélien Rougerie was outstanding after coming on at half-time for Christophe Dominici.

Moment of the match:  The second try from England wing Ben Cohen in the final minutes of the first half wins our vote, after stiff competition from all four other touch-downs by his team, and the moment when French flanker Sébastien Chabal laid his lips on England hooker Steve Thompson in the heat of battle.  But Cohen's try had a shuddering ring of power.  Started by a break from Jonny Wilkinson near the 22, he off-loaded to his left for Will Greenwood, who passed out of the tackle to Cohen at pace, the wing burning a hasty path toward the posts.

Villain of the match:  Some shocking missed tackles blighted the French play, especially early on, so our villainous award goes to the entire French backline's one-on-one defensive efforts.

The teams:

England:  15 Jason Robinson, 14 Ben Cohen, 13 Stuart Abbott, 12 Will Greenwood, 11 Iain Balshaw, 10 Jonny Wilkinson, 9 Kyran Bracken, 8 Martin Corry, 7 Richard Hill, 6 Neil Back, 5 Martin Johnson (c), 4 Ben Kay, 3 Julian White, 2 Steve Thompson, 1 Trevor Woodman
Reserves:  Matt Dawson, Paul Grayson, Jason Leonard, Simon Shaw, Dorian West, Josh Lewsey, Lewis Moody

France:  15 Clement Poitreneaud, 14 Christophe Dominici, 13 Brian Liebenberg, 12 Yannick Jauzion, 11 Xavier Garbajosa, 10 Gerald Merceron, 9 Dimitri Yachvili, 8 Christian Labit, 7 Patrick Tabacco, 6 Sebastien Chabal, 5 Olivier Brouzet, 4 David Auradou, 3 Jean-Baptiste Poux, 2 Raphael Ibanez (c), 1 Olivier Milloud
Reserves:  Yannick Bru, Olivier Magne, Fabien Pelous, Aurelien Rougerie, Sylvain Marconnet
Unused:  Imanol Harinordoquy, Frederic Michalak

The scorers:

For England:
Tries:  Robinson, Balshaw, Cohen 2, Lewsey
Cons:  Wilkinson 3, Grayson
Pens:  Wilkinson 4

For France:
Try:  Rougerie
Pens:  Merceron 2
Drop:  Jauzion

Attendance:  75000
Referee:  Williams n.